Belief is assent to a proposition.
Belief in the
psychological sense, is a
representational mental state
that takes the form of a propositional attitude. In the
religious sense, "belief" refers to a part of a wider spiritual or moral foundation, generally called faith.
Belief is considered propositional in that it is an assertion, claim or expectation about reality that is presumed to be either true or false (even if this cannot be practically determined, such as a
belief in the existence of a particular deity).
Historically,
philosophical attempts to analyze the nature of belief have
been couched in terms of judgement. Both
David Hume and
Immanuel Kant are both particularly well
known for their analyses using this framework.
Belief as an English word has been used in various
ways. In religious contexts it means "faith," whereas in philosophy,
cognitive psychology, and most ordinary contexts, "belief" means
something broader: something like "accept as true." (Analytic
philosophers actually sometimes distinguish belief from acceptance,
however.) Accounts of belief also depend on the object of belief. While
usually
propositions are taken to be the objects of belief, we sometimes
also speak of "believing in" a deity (accepting that the deity exists),
a person (trusting in the person's reliability), and a cause (supporting
a particular value-laden, e.g., political, system of beliefs).
In religious contexts, the word is often restricted to mean
religious beliefs, and in such cases the use of the word often
implies that what is believed cannot be justified conclusively, but
still holds personal and/or social value as valid. See
faith and
faith and rationality.
In
philosophy, historically, attempts to analyze the nature of belief
have been couched in terms of
judgment (this does not imply "value judgment," however--it
means any sort of judgment).
David Hume and
Immanuel Kant are both particularly well-known for their theories of
belief and judgment.
Some beliefs can be
propositional knowledge.
Belief, knowledge and epistemology
Knowledge is often defined as
justified true belief, in that the belief must be considered to correspond to reality and must be derived from
valid evidence and arguments. However, this definition has been challenged by the
Gettier problem which suggests that justified true belief does not provide a complete picture of
knowledge.
To believe something can be interpreted as assigning a
probability of more
than 50% that something is true. The rule of the thumb from a school of
epistemology that says that certainty should be as big as the corresponding evidence is called
evidentialism.
Belief as a psychological theory
Mainstream psychology and related disciplines have traditionally treated
belief as if it were the simplest form of mental representation and therefore one of the building blocks of conscious thought.
Philosophers have tended to be more rigorous in their analysis and much of the work examining the viability of the belief concept
stems from philosophical analysis.
The concept belief presumes a subject (the believer) and an object of belief (the proposition) so like other
propositional attitudes, belief implies the existence of
mental states and
intentionality, both of which are hotly debated topics in the
philosophy of mind and whose foundations and relation to
brain states are still controversial.
Beliefs are sometimes divided into core beliefs (those which you may be actively thinking about) and
dispositional beliefs (those which you may ascribe to but have never previously thought about). For example, if asked
'do you believe tigers wear pink pyjamas ?' a person might answer that they do not, despite the fact they may never have
thought about this situation before.
The idea that a belief is a mental state is much more contentious. While some philosophers have argued that beliefs are represented in the mind as sentence-like constructs others have gone
as far as arguing that there is no consistent or coherent mental representation that underlies our common use of the belief
concept and is therefore obsolete and should be rejected.
This has important implications for understanding the neuropsychology and
neuroscience of belief. If the
concept of belief is incoherent or ultimately indefensible then any attempt to find the underlying neural processes which support
it will fail. If the concept of belief does turn out to be useful then this goal should (in principle) be achievable.
Philosopher
Lynne
Rudder Baker has outlined four main contemporary approaches to belief in her book Saving Belief:
Is belief voluntary?
Most philosophers hold the view that belief formation is to some extent spontaneous and involuntary. Some people think that
one can choose to investigate and research a matter but that one can not choose to believe. On the other hand, most people have
the impression that in some cases people don't believe things because they don't want to believe, especially about a matter in
which they are emotionally involved.
Delusional beliefs
Delusions are defined as beliefs in
psychiatric diagnostic criteria (for example in the
DSM). Psychiatrist and historian
German Berrios has challenged the
view that delusions are genuine beliefs and instead labels them as "empty speech acts", where affected persons are motivated to
express false or bizarre belief statements due to an underlying psychological disturbance. However, the majority of mental health
professionals and researchers treat delusions as if they were genuine beliefs.
The concept of the divine is a key ingredient in all
religious
systems, and it is frequently used to refer to the
monotheistic
God that is part of most of the world's great religions as well as the various
deities that are part of
polytheistic religions such as
Hinduism.
sacred (from Latin, sacrum, "sacrifice")
items are believed by followers to be intimatey connected with the supernatural, or divinity, and are thus greatly revered. For
example,
pagans consider the
Earth sacred,
while Roman Catholics consider the
transubstantiated
host sacred.
Analogously, the word "sacred" is also sometimes used in regard to items highly esteemed by secular institutions or
individuals. For instance, one might say that the
US
government considers the
Stars and Stripes to be sacred.